Re: [Exim] exim 4.10-1 pid issue

Top Page
Delete this message
Reply to this message
Author: Neal D. Becker
Date:  
To: Tony Earnshaw
CC: James P. Roberts, Zander, exim-users
Subject: Re: [Exim] exim 4.10-1 pid issue
>>>>> "Tony" == Tony Earnshaw <tonni@???> writes:

    Tony> fre, 2002-10-11 kl. 21:42 skrev James P. Roberts:
    >> > > Cheers for that, it now works! :o) 1001 didn't show up in either of the
    >> > > files when I greped through them but the chown sorted it.
    >> > Well, it would do.


    >> > And what UID and GID *names* do you have for "1001" on the files in
    >> > those directories?
    >> > "None, actually. Just the numbers."


    >> Technically, only the numbers are important.  Afterall, the system converts the names to numbers before actually doing anything with
    >> them anyway.  And since it worked, then we know that was, indeed, the problem.  He can certainly assign user and group names to
    >> those UID and GID numbers now, at his convenience.  Meanwhile, things are already working for him.


    Tony> There are "right" ways of doing things in Unix, and "wrong" ways.


    Tony> Yours is the "wrong" way.


    Tony> The "right" way is to add the Exim user and group to the Exim config
    Tony> file (as I originally suggested), such that UID/GID mappings are kept
    Tony> constant (there is already an Exim user and an Exim group in /etc/passwd
    Tony> and /etc/group.


    Tony> Using the "wrong" way, you could map Exim users and groups to an
    Tony> infinite number of UID/GID numbers, if you felt so inclined, which would
    Tony> be "A Bad Thing."


As a long time user of exim and Linux, I disagree. If you follow this
advice you will have problems. Packages such as mailman will also
have to be rebuilt. If you want standard RPMS to work, use uid mail
and group mail. There is no reason to make a new exim user or group,
and it will cause problems.