Re: [exim] DMARC spf_domain= empty

On 01/06/17 01:02, Niels Dettenbach via Exim-users wrote:
> Am Mittwoch, 31. Mai 2017, 14:50:16 CEST schrieb Jeremy Harris:
>>> /* Use the envelope sender domain for this part of DMARC */
>>> spf_sender_domain = expand_string(US"$sender_address_domain");
>> It's using $sender_address_domain - so what was that for this mail?
> should be "googlemail.com" in this case, but is empty, if i let write it into
> the log_message from a DMARC acl (in acl_check_data). Within other acls it
> seems properly working. hmm...
Was the message a bounce or autoreply with an empty sender? Should the
behaviour be to fall back to helo domain with spf when
processing a message from the empty sender? Is that even desirable?
>
> The same effect on other sender domains.
>
> It seems that DKIM uses the correct $sender_address_domain and the (libspf2)
> Exim SPF seems to work properly too and .
>
> many thanks for your time!
> many greetings,
>
>
> Niels.