[exim-dev] DANE

Góra strony
Delete this message
Reply to this message
Autor: Jeremy Harris
Data:  
Dla: exim-dev
Stare tematy: Re: [exim-dev] [Bug 1812] New: Minor fixes and clarification of DANE support
Temat: [exim-dev] DANE
[subject changed, as the original bug mail is not relevant]

On 16/04/16 22:27, Viktor Dukhovni wrote:
> I think that the DANE support still needs a bit of work even when
> using OpenSSL.
>
>   * dane_tlsa_load() returns DEFER when after processing all the
>     TLSA records, no usable records are found (e.g. all have
>     certificate usage PKIX-TA(0) or PKIX-EE(1)).  The expected
>     behaviour of opportunistic DANE TLS (rfc7672) in this case is
>     that the delivery will proceed with *unauthenticated* TLS (TLS
>     required, but authentication not required).

>
>     I don't see the code enforces use of TLS when retrying TLS
>     without DANE.


Testcase 5840, subtests 8-10 check this specifically.
Please raise a specific bug if you see one.

>
>   * In same function, the return value of  DANESSL_add_tlsa()
>     might not be used quite right.  It returs 0 when the
>     TLSA record is unusable (say unsupported selector), and
>     negative when encountering an internal error.  Only
>     the negative values should trigger errors.

>
>     default:
>     case 0:     /* action not taken */
>       return tls_error(US"tlsa load", host, NULL);

>
>     The 0 case should be treated just like unusable certificate
>     usages or matching types (continue to next TLSA record).


Seems reasonable. Is documentation for that routine and the
others used for DANE support available yet?

>
>   * TLSA record lookup failures are not handled correctly.
>     If the host's A records are signed,


Signed in what fashion?

> then TLSA record lookup
>     failure must block connections to the host, whether dane is
>     "required" or not.  On the other hand, insecure TLSA records,
>     (CNAME to insecure zone perhaps) should simply be ignored.


--
Jeremy