Lähettäjä: Peter Bowyer Päiväys: Vastaanottaja: exim users Aihe: Re: [exim] SPF Feature - Walk Received header
On 07/05/2009, Marc Perkel <marc@???> wrote: >
>
> Peter Bowyer wrote:
> On 07/05/2009, Marc Perkel <marc@???> wrote: > I'm not currently using SPF but I thought of a feature that mught make SPF > useful. If there were a test that checked all the received lines
> and returned true if any host matched the SPF record it might eliminate > the forwarding issue that SPF breaks.
> That would leave a gaping barn-door-sized hole in SPF - a forger could look > up the SPF record for the domain he was forging, and add a forged Received > header claiming the message had been originated correctly.
I guess you > could apply this rule to a small whitelist of trusted forwarders, though. > But those people should be using SPF/SRS themselves (mine do).
Peter
>
> Granted that a spammer could forge received headers. Most don't.
Eh? Have you looked at many spam samples lately? Or in the last 10 years?
> I'm
> thinking that not bouncing forwarded email is better than the few spammers
> who sneak through.
Not spammers - forgers. Providing a way to defeat an anti-forgery
mechanism wouldn't be my choice. But hey, if that's what you want....
--
Peter Bowyer
Email: peter@???
Follow me on Twitter: twitter.com/peeebeee