Re: [exim] per user spamassassin setup

Startseite
Nachricht löschen
Nachricht beantworten
Autor: Graeme Fowler
Datum:  
To: exim-users
Betreff: Re: [exim] per user spamassassin setup
On Tue, 2006-10-24 at 13:29 -0600, Chris Purves wrote:
> For anyone who is interested, I was able to get exim to call
> spamassassin according to $local_part.
>
> In acl_check_rcpt I added:
>
>   # Set variable for user to be used by spamassassin
>   warn
>     set acl_m0 = $local_part


OK, but...

> Then in acl_check_data I was able to call spamassassin:
>
> spam = $acl_m0


This will only take the last value of acl_m0. Given that any message
could have multiple RCPT TO: statements, with more than one you'll end
up with this running for only the final given recipient.

> This allowed me to get around not being able to use $local_part in
> acl_check_data.


Only partially!

> In order for this to work, spamd be started by root. I also noticed
> that $local_part is specified by the e-mail, not the final delivery
> account as set in /etc/aliases, so mails to postmaster or abuse, for
> example, will not be able to create user_pref files,etc. I am using
> MySQL to store user/bayes/awl settings, so in my case there is no
> problem.


$local_part in the RCPT acl comes from the RCPT TO: statements and will
change with each different one during the RCPT phase. This is what makes
spoofing email addresses so simple, and why we're plagued with what we
are today (in part).

When you get to DATA, the multiple recipients bit is lost, so spamd only
gets called once. For a message with a single recipient that's all well
and good, but for two or more it's broken. By the time you can run the
spam check (at the end of DATA), you only have the option to accept,
reject (or fakereject), or defer the message in its' entirety and not on
a per-user (per-RCPT) basis.

Post-DATA, you can scan the message and then do what many do - if it has
multiple RCPTs, deliver or blackhole|throw_away|filter into folder
according to each user's spam settings. There's a million ways you can
achieve that one!

Graeme