hi fred,
| > You might also want to enable the smtp_return_error_details option at
| > least while debugging.
|
| it already is! :-/
|...
| which is partly why still getting the '550-Admin prohib' is so frustrating
> That can't be.
well, it simply is. :-S
% exim -bP | grep smtp_return_error_details
smtp_return_error_details
> Time to question your assumptions
been doing lots of that ...
> (identifying them is the hard part).
ain't that the truth.
> The evidence seems to show that you're not talking to the exim config you think you are
make a change to my config's banner, reHUP, and send a msg, noting the banner:
-1344204904[1b06f30]: SMTP Response: 220 mail.testdomain.com FRED_IS_A_SKEPTIC ESMTP Mon, 10 Oct
2005 13:27:54 -0700
nope. that's not it ... ;-)
> , or something else unlooked-for is going on.
> Meddling firewall?
none in place for the internal network ...
> Failing to HUP exim after config file changes?
nope.
> Connecting to a different machine?
only one exim to connect to ...
> All seem unlikely for one reason or another, but it will be obvious
once you spot it.
well, it's always true that you find things in the last place you look for them 8-}
> tcpdump or ethereal to see what's really going on
> on the server, compared to what your MUA is logging, may shed some
> light.
probly good next step ...
>> oops. copy/paste error ... that's ONLY for case(2), success ... sorry.
> So what did it look like for case 3? And what did the main log show?
here ya go ...
huh?
exim log -->
2005-10-10 13:38:04 -0700 SMTP connection from [10.0.0.6]:63552 I=[10.0.0.5]:25 (TCP/IP
connection count = 1)
2005-10-10 13:38:05 -0700 IO5VZH-0008MX-1U Subject: t1
2005-10-10 13:38:05 -0700 IO5VZH-0008MX-1U
2005-10-10 13:38:05 -0700 IO5VZH-0008MX-1U <= testuser@??? H=pb1.mydomain.com
[10.0.0.6]:63552 I=[10.0.0.5]:25 P=esmtpsa X=TLSv1:AES256-SHA:256 CV=no
A=sasl_cram_md5:testuser@??? S=1004 id=434AD12A.3060702@??? T="t1" from
<testuser@???> for testuser@???
2005-10-10 13:38:05 -0700 SMTP connection from pb1.mydomain.com [10.0.0.6]:63552 I=[10.0.0.5]:25
closed by QUIT
2005-10-10 13:38:05 -0700 cwd=/var/MailServer/Mail/MailSpool 4 args: /usr/local/exim/bin/exim
-d=0xfbbd5cfd -Mc IO5VZH-0008MX-1U
2005-10-10 13:38:07 -0700 IO5VZH-0008MX-1U => testuser@??? F=<testuser@???>
P=<testuser@???> R=dnslookup_nearby T=remote_smtp S=1030 H=mail.mydomain.com
[10.0.0.2]:25 X=TLSv1:DES-CBC3-SHA:168 CV=no DN="/CN=mail.presence-group.net" C="250 3039341 ok"
QT=2s DT=1s
2005-10-10 13:38:07 -0700 IO5VZH-0008MX-1U Completed QT=2s
exim console output -->
...
11204 => testuser@??? F=<testuser@???> P=<testuser@???>
R=dnslookup_nearby T=remote_smtp S=1035 H=mail.mydomain.com [10.0.0.2]:25
X=TLSv1:DES-CBC3-SHA:168 CV=no DN="/CN=mail.presence-group.net" C="250 3039345 ok" QT=1s DT=1s
11204 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> deliveries are done >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
...
TBird smtp protocol log -->
-1344204904[1b06cf0]: SMTP Send: .
-1344204904[1b06cf0]: SMTP entering state: 0
-1344204904[1b06cf0]: SMTP Response: 250 OK id=IO5W8I-0008N7-0K
-1344204904[1b06cf0]: SMTP entering state: 10
-1344204904[1b06cf0]: SMTP Send: QUIT
-1344204904[1b06cf0]: SMTP entering state: 0
-1344204904[1b06cf0]: SMTP entering state: 0
-1344204904[1b06cf0]: SMTP Response: 221 mail.testdomaim.com closing connection
-1344204904[1b06cf0]: SMTP entering state: 11
-1344204904[1b06cf0]: SMTP entering state: 13
it worked!
wtf? rinse, repeat, try again ... thrash around.
<flame> *&^%*& *&^%())* *&^$^ )(*& )^* </flame>
aha! the problem's Thunderbird. i just realized i tried *THIS* time with the latest beta TBird
version.
v107 (release or nightly) does NOT work.
simply upgrading to Thunderbird v15b2 cures the problem.
argh!!
well, ok. anyway, good to know.
that said, it still does not explain why i'm getting *just* "550 Admin prohibition" w/
smtp_return_error_details set.
btw, thx 4 your help/guidance in this <flame> %**&%@!!!!! </flame> fire-drill!
jeesh ... time for a walk. :-/
richard
--
/"\
\ / ASCII Ribbon Campaign
X against HTML email, vCards
/ \ & micro$oft attachments
[GPG] OpenMacNews
fingerprint: 3F07 3CFD 138A FD91 A4A6 1840 1A7A 8CCB 882F 67A1
