Re: [Exim] Frequent exiwhat executions cause infinite loop o…

Góra strony
Delete this message
Reply to this message
Autor: Philip Hazel
Data:  
Dla: Marcin Owsiany
CC: Exim users mailing list
Temat: Re: [Exim] Frequent exiwhat executions cause infinite loop on smtp delivery
On Wed, 14 Jul 2004, Marcin Owsiany wrote:

> The log contained a reception of a message, but no other activity for that
> message (in case of the second box - for over 2 hours, and in case of the
> second - for over 6 days, even though the final retry cutoff time is 4 days!)


Thanks for the report and the detailed debugging information.

> I don't know why the timeout was 600 seconds, since I have not changed the
> default, which is documented to be 5 minutes (smtp_receive_timeout),


The final timeout at the end of a message has a longer default (10
minutes).

> | /* Wait until the socket is ready */
> |
> | for (;;)
> |   {
> |   FD_ZERO (&select_inset);
> |   FD_SET (sock, &select_inset);
> |   tv.tv_sec = timeout;
> |   tv.tv_usec = 0;
> |   rc = select(sock + 1, (SELECT_ARG2_TYPE *)&select_inset, NULL, NULL, &tv);
> |
> |   /* If some interrupt arrived, just retry. We presume this to be rare,
> |   but it can happen (e.g. the SIGUSR1 signal sent by exiwhat causes
> |   select() to exit). */
> |
> |   if (rc < 0 && errno == EINTR)
> |     {
> |     HDEBUG(D_any) debug_printf("EINTR while selecting for socket read\n");
> |     continue;
> |     }

>
> Apparently the delivery process has spent 6 days hanging like this, by having
> its select() timeout reset to 10 minutes by exiwhat every two minutes.


Aarrgghh!! Nasty.

> I don't exactly understand why the TCP connection wasn't simply terminated by
> the remote host?


You would think so, but there are oddities in TCP/IP stacks that I do
not pretend to understand.

> Anyway, can this be worked around at least for the systems which update the
> struct timeval in case of EINTR? Or maybe even for all other, by manually
> comparing time() before select() and after it's interrupted?


Good idea. I will do something like that, but it is too late for 4.40,
which was released a few hours ago.

--
Philip Hazel            University of Cambridge Computing Service,
ph10@???      Cambridge, England. Phone: +44 1223 334714.
Get the Exim 4 book:    http://www.uit.co.uk/exim-book