RE: FW: [Exim] BCC list at first MTA in chain - Any list, tw…

Top Pagina
Delete this message
Reply to this message
Auteur: Philip Hazel
Datum:  
Aan: David Woodhouse
CC: Boyle Owen, Exim list
Onderwerp: RE: FW: [Exim] BCC list at first MTA in chain - Any list, two MTAsin series..
On 10 Mar 2003, David Woodhouse wrote:

> Well, it's not _quite_ perfect but it's close. Going back to the
> example, if it transpired that 'anotherdomain' and 'yetanotherdomain'
> are both clients of the same hosting provider, and so the mail for both
> is in fact being sent to the _same_ remote host, Exim isn't going to
> notice that, and hence is still going to make two separate connections
> to the same machine.


Ahem. Exim is cleverer than you think. It notices identical host lists
that are generated from different domains. However, it doesn't try to be
more clever than that. For example, if you have:

dom1   MX  1  host1
       MX  1  host2


dom2   MX  2  host2
       MX  2  host1


it will use a single connection (yes, it spots the different order for
identical MX values). But if you have

dom1   MX  1  host1
       MX  1  host2


dom2   MX  2  host1
       MX  2  host3


it concludes that the host lists are different.

> And as Phil just said -- other MTAs won't necessarily be as efficient,
> although I think most should.


qmail makes a virtue of delivering each address in a separate
connection, as I understand it.

--
Philip Hazel            University of Cambridge Computing Service,
ph10@???      Cambridge, England. Phone: +44 1223 334714.