Re: [EXIM] wish list: exit number translation ?

Startseite
Nachricht löschen
Nachricht beantworten
Autor: Peter Radcliffe
Datum:  
To: exim-users
Betreff: Re: [EXIM] wish list: exit number translation ?
Philip Hazel <ph10@???> probably said:
> On Tue, 29 Sep 1998, Peter Radcliffe wrote:
> >     Child process of procmail_pipe transport returned 67 from command:
> > While this is useful, its not very informative to those who don't know
> > about the existance of sysexits.h.

>
> The problem is that a process started by Exim to run a pipe is entirely
> at liberty to return any exit code it fancies. The definitions in
> sysexits.h don't seem to have any force of standardization, and indeed,
> the comment in the file on Solaris 2.5 says:


The problem, as you say, is non-standards.

> > Wish list: translation of the exit code to some more informative text.
> > There doesn't seem to be a standard function to do this, but a case
> > on EX_foo should be correct.
> > Since not all programs will return standard exit codes, be able to turn
> > it off/on for particular pipe transports ?


... which is why I suggested being able to turn it on/off, so if you know
something does/doesn't return the sysexits codes, you can change it
as appropriate.

> Perhaps I can dream up some wording along the line of "a common meaning
> of this code is xxxx, but your mileage may vary". For the signals, one


I thought about that, but users get confused enough by bounce messages
when the wording is clear and simple :(

> can be more definite. This won't be in the next release because I want
> to get that out quite quickly for the bug fix.


Fairy Snuff.

James FitzGibbon <james@???> probably said:
> exit_code_messages = dbm;/opt/mail/etc/exit_code_messages.db ?
>
> Just a thought. It would be simple to make a small program to iterate
> through sysexits.h and produce a sample text file suitable for
> exim_builddbm. Users could then change the messages or add new ones if
> their installation required it.


I think James has a good idea here, have a standard db file for sysexits
codes and be able to define more of your own for anything else ...

P.

-- 
pir               pir@???      pir@???      pir@???



--
*** Exim information can be found at http://www.exim.org/ ***