Re: [Exim] Callout timeouts: opinions sought

Top Page
Delete this message
Reply to this message
Author: Andrzej Filip
Date:  
To: exim-users
Subject: Re: [Exim] Callout timeouts: opinions sought
Philip Hazel wrote:
> It has been pointed out that the callout timeout, e.g. as set by
>
> verify = sender/callout=10s
>
> applies to individual connections and commands within the callout. If a
> domain has a very large number of hosts (and some do have dozens: look
> at newsabuse.net) and all of them are timing out, the overall time taken
> for the callout to fail can be riduculously long. This can cause trouble
> further back.
>
> I think it is clear that we need an overall timeout on the callout
> process. The question is whether
>
>   (a) To invent a totally new parameter ("overall callout timeout");
>   OR
>   (b) The redefine the existing callout time to be an overall timeout as
>       well as a timeout on individual connections and SMTP commands.
>   OR
>   (c) To take some multiple of the existing callout time (e.g. 4 times).

>
> The default timeout, incidentally, is 30s.
>
> I feel that inventing a totally new parameter is making this whole thing
> too complicated, but you may think differently.
>
> Opinions?


What do you think about yet another timeout for connect only ?

From my experience it makes difference if you wait for connection
establishment or response over established connection.

--
Andrzej [en:Andrew] Adam Filip anfi@??? anfi@???
http://anfi.homeunix.net/ http://anfi.homeunix.net/exim/